How I would build a crisis response team today

Abby Mangold Working with small team

This is how I would build a crisis response team today (in the age of AI and fake videos).

This is based on what I have seen work when scrutiny is high and the margin for error is small.

First, I look for judgement before speed.

Fast reactions feel competent, but poor decisions travel quickly and are hard to pull back.

Second, I want people who are comfortable saying “we do not know yet”.

Credibility is damaged far more by speculating than by honesty.

Third, strong writing under pressure matters more than ever. Clear sentences. Plain language. No internal jargon.

If your team cannot write well at speed, no tool will fix it – even AI.

Fourth, human insight cannot be automated.

AI can summarise information.

It cannot read fear, anger or uncertainty in an audience.

Fifth, senior leaders value people who are willing to challenge them.

The right advice can be unpopular.

The strongest crisis teams stop bad decisions early.

Sixth, understanding how the media actually work is non-negotiable.

Not how organisations wish it worked.

Headlines, timelines and silence all carry consequences.

Finally, rehearsal beats reaction every time.

The most effective crisis teams I have worked with have practised long before they needed to perform.

AI can support crisis communications BUT It will not replace judgement, preparation or leadership under pressure.

If you are reviewing your crisis readiness for the year ahead, this is the capability mix I would prioritise if  building a crisis response team today.

Get in touch to find out more how Mangold Consultancy can help with your crisis readiness

The first hour crisis blueprint

first hour crisis blueprint

When the unexpected hits, the first 60 minutes decide everything.

In those moments, instinct kicks in but instinct without a plan can quickly unravel.

That’s why I run “first hour” drills with leadership teams.

We walk through what to do minute by minute: fact-checking, activating the right people, monitoring, and getting clear messages out fast.

It’s not theory. It’s practice.

Because in a real crisis, you don’t rise to the occasion you fall back on your training.

👉 Curious what that looks like? This is the blueprint I use to help leaders prepare.

The first hour crisis blueprint

What to do when the clock starts…

  • 0–10 mins Check facts from source. No speculation
  • 10–20 mins Initiate Crisis Management team, brief Crisis Comms agency and switch on social media monitoring.
  • 20–30 mins Agree and issue holding statement.
  • 30–45 mins Draft follow up internal and external comms (concise, clear, calm).
  • 45–60 mins Issue updated comms.

Act Now Debrief later

Why crisis communication readiness protects reputation

Crisis communication readiness with Mangold Consultancy.

In 80% of crises I handle, the damage isn’t caused by the event itself

It is caused by what is said or not said in the first 24 hours.

I have seen small incidents spiral into national headlines because leaders guessed their way through the response.

I have also seen major crises vanish from public conversation in days because the messaging was prepared in advance.

Crisis communication is not spin.

  • It is readiness.
  • It is knowing what to say before you have to say it.

If you want that level of readiness for your organisation, we should talk now, not when the crisis has already arrived.